When most archers shop for fletching, the question is usually, "Which vane is best?" At 1 Arrow Archery, we approached the problem differently. Instead of trying to design one product that does everything, we developed two products with two distinct purposes.
1Vane was engineered primarily for whitetail hunting, where reducing an arrow's acoustic signature can be an important consideration. 1Wing was developed for western hunting, long-range shooting, and 3D target archery, where stability, forgiveness, and consistent arrow flight at extended distances become the priority.
The result isn't two competing products—it's two tools designed for different jobs.
There Is No "Perfect" Vane
Every vane design represents a balance between several aerodynamic characteristics:
Improving one characteristic often affects another. That's why engineers don't design airplanes, Formula One cars, or arrows around a single measurement.
The same philosophy guided the development of both 1Vane and 1Wing.
1Vane: Developed for Whitetail Hunting
Whitetail deer have exceptional hearing and can react to sound before an arrow arrives. While shot placement will always be the most important factor, reducing unnecessary arrow noise was one of the design goals behind 1Vane.
Independent testing by The Archery Sound Lab showed 1Vane produced a deer-weighted sound level of 55.2 dBZ.
When compared against the vanes evaluated in the study, deer-weighted sound levels ranged from 48.7 dBZ to 60.7 dBZ.
That places 1Vane squarely in the quieter half of all vane designs tested, while still providing the stabilization hunters expect.
Deer-weighted vane sound comparison
Lower deer-weighted dBZ values indicate less sound in frequencies most audible to whitetail deer.
Although some vanes measured quieter, the testing shows that 1Vane performs competitively while balancing sound, stability, and durability for hunting applications.
1Wing: Designed for Long-Range Performance
While 1Vane emphasized acoustic performance, 1Wing followed a different design philosophy.
Western hunters often shoot:
…at distances where wind drift, broadhead control, and repeatable arrow flight become increasingly important.
For those applications, aerodynamic stability becomes more valuable than minimizing every decibel of sound.
The 1Wing measured an average sound level of 59.2 dBZ deer-weighted.
That places it toward the upper end of the acoustic range tested, but that should not be viewed as a weakness. It reflects a deliberate engineering tradeoff in favor of long-range flight characteristics rather than prioritizing the quietest possible acoustic signature.
If your typical shot is 50 to 80 yards across an open canyon, those aerodynamic characteristics may matter more than small differences in sound.
Broadheads Often Have an Even Bigger Impact
One of the most interesting findings from the Precision Cut Archery Arrow Ballistics Study is that broadheads can influence arrow noise as much—or even more—than the vane itself.
The study found that changing from a field point to different fixed-blade broadheads significantly altered the arrow's acoustic profile.
Across the tested combinations, complete arrow systems ranged from approximately the low-50 dB range with the quietest configurations to roughly the 70 dB range with the loudest fixed-blade combinations.
In other words:
A quiet vane paired with a loud broadhead may produce a louder arrow than a slightly louder vane paired with a more aerodynamic broadhead.
That reinforces an important point:
Arrow sound should always be evaluated as a complete system—not as an individual component.
Every Component Works Together
Arrow flight depends on numerous variables:
No single component determines success.
That's why both 1Vane and 1Wing were engineered as part of an overall arrow system rather than as isolated products.
One Arrow. Two Personalities.
One advantage unique to the 1 Arrow Archery system is that switching between 1Vane and 1Wing is quick and straightforward.
If your fall starts with August antelope season followed by September elk season and ends in a November whitetail stand, you don't necessarily need to build entirely new arrows.
You can simply remove one style and install the other to optimize your setup for the hunt ahead.
That flexibility allows archers to adapt their equipment without replacing complete arrow builds.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose 1Vane if you primarily:
Choose 1Wing if you primarily:
Final Thoughts
The testing tells an important story.
Independent acoustic testing showed 1Vane at 55.2 dBZ deer-weighted, placing it in the quieter half of the tested vane designs and aligning with its original purpose as a whitetail hunting vane.
Meanwhile, the 1Wing configuration measured 59.2 dBZ, illustrating the different design priorities associated with long-range performance.
Just as importantly, the Precision Cut Archery Arrow Ballistics Study reminds us that broadhead selection can change arrow sound by nearly 20 dB across tested configurations, meaning the entire arrow system—not just the vane—determines what game animals hear.
At 1 Arrow Archery, we don't believe every hunter needs the same solution.
We believe every hunter deserves the right solution.
Research Note: Performance and sound data referenced in this article are derived from independent testing conducted by The Archery Sound Lab and publicly available research published by Precision Cut Archery. Unless otherwise stated, comparisons are based on each organization's published testing methodology. Because testing protocols differ between organizations, direct comparisons between studies should be interpreted accordingly.
Leave a comment